Why the raids on Australian media present a clear threat to democracy


June 05, 2019 18:31:35

The Australian Federal Police has this week conducted two high-profile raids on journalists who have exposed government secrets and their sources.

On Tuesday, seven AFP officers spent several hours searching News Corp journalist Annika Smethurst’s Canberra home, her mobile phone and computer. The AFP linked the raid to “the alleged publishing of information classified as an official secret”.

This stemmed from Smethurst’s 2018 article, which contained images of a “top secret” memo and reported that senior government officials were considering moves to empower the Australian Signals Directorate (ASD) to covertly monitor Australian citizens for the first time.

Soon after, 2GB Radio Presenter Ben Fordham revealed he had been notified by the Department of Home Affairs that he was the subject of a similar investigation, aimed at identifying the source of classified information he had reported regarding intercepted boat arrivals.

And then on Wednesday, the AFP raided the ABC’s Sydney headquarters. This dramatic development was in connection with the 2017 Afghan Files report based on “hundreds of pages of secret Defence Force documents leaked to the ABC”. These documents revealed disturbing allegations of misconduct by Australian special forces.

The reaction to the raids was immediate and widespread.

The New York Times quoted News Corp’s description of the Smethurst raid as “a dangerous act of intimidation towards those committed to telling uncomfortable truths”. The Prime Minister was quick to distance his Government from the AFP’s actions, while Opposition Leader Anthony Albanese condemned the raids.

But to those familiar with the ever-expanding field of Australian national security law, these developments were unlikely to surprise. In particular, enhanced data surveillance powers and a new suite of secrecy offences introduced in late 2018 had sparked widespread concern over the future of public interest journalism in Australia.

The crackdown of the past few days reveals that at least two of the core fears expressed by lawyers and the media industry were well-founded: first, the demise of source confidentiality and, secondly, a chilling effect on public interest journalism.

Source confidentiality

Upon finding out he was the subject of an investigation aimed at uncovering his sources of government information, Ben Fordham declared:

“The chances of me revealing my sources is zero. Not today, not tomorrow, next week or next month. There is not a hope in hell of that happening.”

Source confidentiality is one of journalists’ most central ethical principles. It is recognised by the United Nations and is vital to a functioning democracy and free, independent, robust and effective media.

One of the greatest threats to source confidentiality is Australia’s uniquely broad data surveillance framework. The 2015 metadata retention scheme requires that all metadata (that is, data about a device or communication but not, say, the communication itself) be retained for two years. It may then be covertly accessed by a wide array of government agencies without a warrant. Some reports suggest that by late 2018, some 350,000 requests for access to metadata were being received by telecommunications service providers each year.

The Government was not blind to the potential impact of this scheme on source confidentiality. For example, obtaining metadata relating to a journalist’s mobile phone could reveal where they go and who they contact and easily point to their sources.

This led to the introduction of the “Journalist Information Warrant” (JIW). This warrant is required if an agency wishes to access retained metadata for the direct purpose of identifying a professional journalist’s source.

So, access to a professional journalist’s metadata in order to identify a confidential source is permitted, provided the access has a particular criminal investigation or enforcement purpose and the agency can show it is in the public interest and therefore obtain a JIW.

This week’s raids suggest that either JIWs could not be obtained in relation to Smethurst, Fordham or the ABC journalists, or the journalists’ metadata did not reveal their sources, or the AFP did not attempt to access their metadata.

Alternatively, if metadata had identified the journalists’ sources, it is less clear why these dramatic developments took place.

After 2015, journalists were advised to avoid using their mobile devices in source communications. They were also encouraged, wherever possible, to encrypt communications.

But in 2018, the Government went some way to closing down this option when it introduced the complex and highly controversial Telecommunications and Other Legislation Amendment (Assistance and Access) Act 2018.

As well as expanding computer access and network access warrants, the Act provided a means for Government agencies to co-opt those in the telecommunications industry to assist agencies with their investigations. This could include covertly installing weaknesses and vulnerabilities in specific devices, circumventing passwords or allowing encrypted communications to be decrypted. A warrant would then be required to access the device and communication data.

It is impossible to know whether Australian journalists have been targeted under the Act or had weaknesses or spyware installed on their personal devices. This week’s raids suggest the AFP would be prepared to target journalists under this framework in order to identify journalists’ confidential sources.

However, this could only be done for some purposes, including in the investigation of a secrecy offence.

Secrecy offences

In June 2018, the Government introduced a suite of new espionage, foreign interference and secrecy offences. This included an offence of current or former Commonwealth officers communicating information, obtained by virtue of their position, likely to cause harm to Australia’s interests. This offence is punishable by imprisonment for seven years. If the information is security classified or the person held a security classification, then they may have committed an “aggravated offence” and be subject to 10 years’ imprisonment.

This week’s raids reveal just how common it is for public interest journalism to rely on secret material and Government sources.

But the journalists themselves may also be facing criminal prosecution. The 2018 changes include a “general secrecy offence”, whereby it is an offence (punishable by imprisonment for five years) to communicate classified information obtained from a Commonwealth public servant. Fordham’s radio broadcast about intercepted boat arrivals was, for example, a clear communication of classified information.

Again, journalists are offered some protection. If prosecuted, a journalist can seek to rely on the “journalism defence” by proving that they dealt with the information as a journalist, and that they reasonably believed the communication to be in the public interest. The meaning of “public interest” is unclear and, in this context, untested. However, it will take into account the public interest in national security and government integrity secrecy concerns as well as openness and accountability.

Protecting media freedom

Australia has more national security laws than any other nation. It is also the only liberal democracy lacking a Charter of Human Rights that would protect media freedom through, for example, rights to free speech and privacy.

In this context, journalists are in a precarious position — particularly journalists engaged in public interest journalism. This journalism is vital to government accountability and a vibrant democracy, but has a tense relationship with Australia’s national interests as conceived by government.

National security law has severely undercut source confidentiality by increasing and easing data surveillance. National security laws have also criminalised a wide array of conduct related to the handling of sensitive government information, both by Government officers and the general public.

And these laws are just a few parts of a much larger national security framework that includes: control orders, preventative detention orders, ASIO questioning and detention warrants, secret evidence, and offences of espionage, foreign interference, advocating or supporting terrorism and more.

JIWs, and the inclusion of a journalism defence to the secrecy offence, recognise the importance of a free press. However, each of these protections relies on a public interest test. When Government claims of national security and the integrity of classifications is weighed into this balance, it is difficult to see how other interests might provide an effective counterbalance.

One of the most disturbing outcomes is not prosecutions or even the raids themselves, but the chilling of public interest journalism. Sources are less likely to come forward, facing risk to themselves and a high likelihood of identification by Government agencies. And journalists are less likely to run stories, knowing the risks posed to their sources and perhaps even to themselves.

Against this background, the calls for a Media Freedom Act, such as by the Alliance for Journalists’ Freedom, have gained significant traction. It may take this kind of bold statement to cut across the complexities of individual laws and both recognise and protect the basic freedom of the press and the future of public interest journalism in Australia.

Rebecca Ananian-Welsh is Senior Lecturer at the TC Beirne School of Law at The University of Queensland. This piece first appeared on The Conversation.












Source link

About the Author

Australia News
More Than 20 Years in News and jobs

45 Comments on "Why the raids on Australian media present a clear threat to democracy"

  1. Hi, i believe that i saw you visited my weblog thus i came to “go back the favor”.I am attempting to find things to enhance my site!I suppose its adequate to use a few of your concepts!!

  2. i just wanted to help be grateful for this. it allowed me to quite a lot which has a job i merely done. initially we tried out just using simplexml to study any 400mb xml data and also very well, php weren’t having that. now this could create 20k records but it really deletes these when it’s performed in addition to every little thing is actually functioning fantastic. thank you!
    coque iphone https://themusicsyndicate.com/?p=6630

  3. I aquired photovault the other day and i also must say On the web Pleased from it. The ipod touch’s picture collection has been fairly substandard in my view… THIS alternatively is great. We didn’t rather need the power to pass word issues off of (though it can be neat)- privately I aquired the idea so I can actually organize my photographs and not having to lie on a pc that version utilizing itunes (VERY inconvenient).
    coque iphone http://www.tandartsreitsma.nl/?p=22462

  4. Elaborate the simplest way to receive the ssh crucial to the particular apple ipad with no emailing the idea?
    coque iphone https://www.missparadise.com.br/blog/?p=363

  5. My spouse and i set this kind of way up these days out in the residence check lab with all the goal involving replicating this endeavours at the office about Sunday.
    coque iphone https://ko.teles-relay.com/?p=328717

  6. My spouse and i attempted the idea once more right now and also although it previously worked, it was a little while until for a long time for you to get it. (2 minutes)
    coque iphone http://www.cmbelagua.com/?p=13191

  7. Main kudos Jesse about an additional awesome useful resource that can help the complete market.
    coque iphone http://www.casa-enrique.nl/?p=1047

  8. To tell the truth, My spouse and i did not anticipate like ipad device from Apple mackintosh. . -= Aminul Mahometismo Sajib’s continue website… Yahoo and google Authority Updated: AISajib. com has become PR3! =-.
    coque iphone http://5a7beaute.com/?p=36627

  9. Cheers a great deal, this info seemed to be spot on to me. I will bookmark this page intended for future upadtes. Thanks all over again.
    coque iphone

  10. sirsome cellular material are generally not editable. how does many of us edit these individuals Their Superb Software program,,,,, Their very helpful. Please recommend intended for editing and enhancing the option of “Person in charge of Sighning”.
    coque iphone http://casaluma.staging.truecode.pt/?p=13814

  11. Range retail the way to goFriday Reflections SIMPLY BY F. K. Sidhu
    coque iphone https://dscteam.ru/?p=4303

  12. The particular constraint occur to be managing facing usually are your pre-conceived images in the platforms (tablets, etc)
    coque iphone https://www.coinvoice.kr/?p=37052

  13. Wendy & Ron, we are certainly not dealing with Atmosphere being an ISP, we are merely referring to Sky’s software program that they can give to be able to buyers that contain the internet connection link referred to as Sky By simply Broadband’ which is maltreating each of our bandwidth. There exists absolutely nothing drastically wrong with Sky as a possible INTERNET SERVICE PROVIDER in terms of i’m informed.
    coque iphone http://internetrat.at/?p=14442

  14. I would like to communicate as a result of anyone regarding rescuing my family with this type of circumstance. Just after browsing through the internet and conference methods wasn’t beneficial, My partner and i assumed warring was around. Active without the actual approaches to the problems an individual has categorized out by means of your entire write-ups is often a vital circumstance, as well as kinds that could get negatively ruined this entire profession merely had not experienced your website. Your personal true understanding and also kindness with holding every part ended up being valuable. We need ideas things i would’ve carried out merely hadn’t occur on this sort of stage in this way. I can also during this period thrive on the potential. Thanks a lot a great deal to your professional along with useful support. I won’t think twice in order to advise the web site to some person who will be required assistance relating to this matter.
    coque iphone http://green.greensoft.ro/?p=2153

  15. Can anyone you should explaine to me the way to get rid of the pastime food list through the elgg web site as well as edit typically the my own and good friends web site because i have to have. I want to alter the file format on the display whenever mentioned about the picture Fine site it is, I use book marked this within my flock, regards.
    coque iphone http://datajuice.vsb.cz/?p=40434

  16. Anybody is usually curious, this great article “Mitt Romney’ nasiums Extraordinarily Dangerous Penny-Pinching Compulsion” by means of Alex MacGillis with the New Republic web page shows exactly why Romney is absolutely appropriate to never relieve further tax returns, not really much like a comma a lot more. Just simply check out this crap to see what steps out there to the weeds a fervent reportorial con artisan like MacGillis goes any time provided nothing of importance or maybe fascination. This can be a work of art of unnecessary mudslinging in relation to hidden conditions inside taxes code that completely convince Mr.. MacGillis in which Romney is often a POOR PERSON. some remarkable nThe taxes and tax returns of a productive entrepreneur, it should be met with not strange, are usually complicated issues. To evaluate them correctly needs the abilities of your accountant plus a duty lawyer. Solely after that, after executing people mind-numbing assignments, might everyone able to to find involving what exactly is right and inappropriate, genuine and also bogus. Mister MacGillis nonetheless wants every person in order to by pass right to typically the justice period no reach this into the penalty level. Romney’s prosperous. He has exercised duty breaks. Bad? Of course your dog is sinful. Along with MacGillis’ became barrows brimming with beautifully confusing and also hopelessly thorough info to pass through the particular hurdle course of his or her convoluted, thought-deadening, ahem, writing type. d nThe previous couple of weeks have shown beyond reach of cavil the fact that offender organization usually known as typically the Obama for Chief executive Campaign has used LYING DOWN AS BEING A PLANNED METHOD. Ala Coleman their particular motto is definitely “Just state it! ” Correctly, often the Democrats want nothing a lot better than to inveigle their particular mass media allies straight into shelling out the next ninety days undertaking very little but groing through Romney’s fees collection through line (and everybody knows how the mass media have to have precious minor with respect to inveigling). And just in the event we people would likely actually relatively not necessarily, in the event we would prefer gouging available our own sight in comparison with digging including termites directly into 4000 webpages involving taxes and tax returns, accepted and also separate authorities much like the income tax wizards Hair Blitzer, Erin Burnett, Donald Gregory, often the aforesaid Mister. MacGillis, and George Stephanopoulos is usually depended on to describe to us all exactly how sketchy in addition to our many advantages! quite possibly exactly how illegitimate the particular deductions believed online 53 of supplemental timetable T (as corrected 1983) more than likely is actually; not even mentioning that stated consumer credit is within abuse of Section 200-1g (section 512, subsection LII, section 69) in the Utah taxes computer, as well as aiding, about, the actual having of an lawbreaker actions against the Governor because he or she evaded reporting gains gained via whitened slavery in violation with the Promoting Moonshine for you to Mormons Take action regarding 1934, along with why don’t we just simply schedule the months of Aug as well as October to essentially be able to underneath of this. and nCats will probably follow pets in addition to snow fall dark previous to we ought to ever see a finish to the discussion.
    coque iphone https://den.o3000.ru/?p=389

  17. Taking is actually poor… millimeter kay! RIAA through says damage… Pay money for your current songs, avoid acquire it.
    coque iphone https://www.daviddeyong.co.uk/blog/?p=148

  18. Fine collection the following. My partner and i never have heard of many of them nevertheless experimented with Groove Shark some time backside. They have a big simple web-site to utilize in addition to lots of music to select from. Have to attempt the rest at some point!
    coque iphone https://intux.de/?p=19917

  19. At the moment ATM skimming could difficult issue, Thanks for expressing this particular post. This can be a great and also useful for everyone.
    coque iphone http://iplushub.isso.cool/?p=10527

  20. please explaine to me a person could not simply make use of a wikipedia web-site to try to demonstrate a time……
    coque iphone https://destroyerhosting.com/positivepaper/?p=15824

  21. also can allow you to “Make your art work look like garbage. inch Have a look at his / her produced this kind of company logo idea regarding my own design enterprise following going through Von Glitscha’s reserve, Vector Standard Schooling. He / she represents his / her whole inventive method by drawing bad thumbnails “analog” fashion,
    coque iphone https://www.daviddeyong.co.uk/blog/?p=342

  22. We stumbled across exactly the same concern if originally I used to be attempting to work out the reason why issues ended up consuming that long to help down load because of this support. I had fashioned the particular social networking tab displaying inside the Microsoft windows Taaskmgr and remarked that after i cigarettes from your system, my multilevel connection should still be getting used. With testing more I discovered that even if We closed typically the PERSONAL COMPUTER as well as rebooted my community connection should still be getting used with program.
    coque iphone http://electricdistro.com/blog/?p=3435

  23. Wonderful, good goods gentleman. I am just a keen fan. Continue.
    coque iphone http://dev-blogs.fullclasificados.ec/autos/?p=762

  24. inside Songza information you actually declare we live in a renaissance of social media marketing.. by the way signifies “rebirth” and also to the expertise social media marketing is reasonably completely new, consequently creating this a genesis or innovation. I am sorry like a yank this aimed that will available.
    coque iphone http://hao.jser.com/?p=29524

  25. Very good article to evaluate hidden persons. But I am furthermore seeking the idea to get Skype ip telefoni hey, right now yahoo features patched brand-new detect procedure additionally we will have to hang on some more time regarding internet marketing imperceptable to work completely: )
    coque iphone http://www.bbbb.cm/?p=1792

  26. I simply set up the particular app. My partner and i renamed the actual “first record, micron designated this the password, after that attemptedto importance some examination pics from the camera roll. From a minute perhaps, the app crashed. I actually opened it online backup. I actually clicked on the lp (to find out if the particular pictures possessed brought in as well as not). While i enter into our password, the whole iphone app failures. At the beginning, I assumed I would possess entered the actual pass word incorrectly, although really completed the same with regards to ten times currently. Do they offer fix just for this?
    coque iphone http://booking.lodge-in-garden.com/?p=12689

  27. More like, nearby MARKET other people’s new music you may okay. Critically, I hesitation any guys r gonna try to sell a Dork Matthew’s melody within their own identify.
    coque iphone http://wordpress.logoinn.me/car-care/?p=38654

  28. Cheers a great deal, this info had been spot on for me personally. I’ll save this website with regard to foreseeable future upadtes. Thank you all over again.
    coque iphone https://www.schugartec-hude.de/?p=15289

  29. SIMPLY NO I havent screened this still, but computer chip goes Windows Safe-keeping Hardware intended for his vSphere area consequently unwell always mention that to be able to the pup intended for if he attempts to improvement. We shall determine all of our usage Performed a person ever produce WSS iSCSI concentrate on consult with ESXi five. 0 Never have tried… do they offer known challenge? I actually prefer to improvement the co-workers bunch thurs . night and is using WSS as their SAN
    coque iphone http://www.nokia-touch.fr/?p=24135

  30. Basically, let alone. It looks like I had method the LUNs effectively, the problem has been along with ESXi not joining accurately over the GUI. I had formed right away to support the particular LUNs:
    coque iphone https://np-presidentsclub.idexx.com/?p=304

  31. Sherri Now i am looking to buy method to consider photographs offmy apple iphone photograph burial container and put these individuals with mymy i-pad2 photo container support My spouse and i did not remember my pass word as well as seemed to be asking yourself if there ended up being at any rate to be able to reset the item in case I could place in ceiling protection concerns if it occurs yet again I actually no longer wish to reduce my very own pics inside therefore please assist me to SHORTLY thanks a lot Yet another thing I’ve discovered is actually this for many, crooked credit score could be the response to situation further than their very own manage. For instance they will often has been saddled with the illness so they really obviously have excessive charges planning to series. It might be because of a work reduction or even not able to the office. Often breakup or maybe separating may definitely deliver the fiscal conditions within the undesirable direction. Cheers expressing your thinking for this internet site.
    coque iphone https://www.eholiday.pl/blog/?p=5091

  32. Could a person codes the on the web traditional listing reader, similar to Friend Secret agent. So We can certainly weight all of our written text document comprising namesscann. In this article most of us get away from Songs online. anyone knows Program!
    coque iphone https://www.blossominggifts.com/blog/?p=3008

  33. Each and every software or application possesses the advantages along with crons and so the completely incorrect sighting the particular awful details about that. It includes most of the very good items so that as some time passes these types of weak points will likely be soughted out and about. . -= GadgetGuide4U’s very last website… Stumbleupon Software package Intended for Google android has become Avaiable =-.
    coque iphone https://den.o3000.ru/?p=357

  34. that, amongst others, shows Canadians whether their very own internet connection provider (ISP) uses Serious Box Check up technologies or perhaps DOTS PER INCH. ISPs work with DPI to see exactly what software individuals are serves to choose versions Deep supply inspection (DPI) represents the latest period of time from the historical past regarding social manage and, again, we must problem often the state policies involving management embedded inside engineering. The manage inserted within DPI deviates in the architectural mastery involving overpasses; DOTS PER INCH goes by way of software program therefore their style of command is somewhat more water when compared with real. Management will not block, yet operates by “increasing the possibility of your wanted result instead of their definite determination” (Samarajiva, 1996, p. 129). The Internet presents itself start even so the maussade computer software regarding strong supply evaluation at this point subtly regulates World wide web site visitors through gently powering the marketing communications directly into quick in addition to gradual lanes. [1] With this quick essay or dissertation I am going to discover what is significant regarding DPI’s ability to handle devices. I really do so frist by own naming the nature of this kind of manage, second of all painting it is surgery, last but not least simply by estimating within the challenges the item positions to democratic community.
    coque iphone http://demo5.ostpl.in/shekareye/?p=81079

  35. My spouse and i tried checking out your web site along with my very own apple, ipod touch as well as the layout does not are correct. May want to check it out on WAP and it appears most cell phone cool layouts aren’t truly cooperating with your website.
    coque iphone https://blog.uniquepalette.com/?p=118701

  36. You didn’t remember to incorporate Playlist. com, exactly where it isn’t possibly important for that you sign-up and steady stream almost any melody you would like.
    coque iphone https://www.mindsky.com/?p=63636

  37. You should be capable of create some sort of ruke regarding Kontiji assists and khost with a firewall. Think about moving get record to different directory website, observe file spot with SBB options, you are watch document using your mass media participant as the driver’s licence is actually for this file definitely not SBB, remen=mber for you to get rid of the main obtain, This should work My spouse and i could hardly even obtain the computer software in order to acquire. Happy I came across in this article, shalln’t possibly work with that currently. Dvd videos tend to be low-priced ample right now and a lot more expensive Pleased anyone had written about this. The easiest way to get at Sky is always to statement these to Offcom and also just about every target audience who scans this would support Watchdog, adequate men and women complaining about it is going to allow it to become newsworthy.
    coque iphone http://lss.ow.cz/?p=5671

  38. I’ve truly installed/used skybb for just a 1 week at this point rather than recognized that right up until We came on this website via a arbitrary search engines…
    coque iphone https://om-star.ru/?p=7080

  39. Theres a good one on my telephone named deadbeat radio… I use an android, consequently idk if you find a computer site That’s why slacker absolutely has a laptop or computer web site. It has the excellent. Enjoy deadbeat. They get much more audio when compared with pandora bracelets and also you dont receive the same amount of saying again items.
    coque iphone http://codu.vn/?p=5966

  40. Apple mackintosh terminated often the update yesterday due to the method iTunes Syncing had been empowered. However , I will make it better nowadays and resubmit the particular up-date for you to the apple company. Ideally will probably be permitted quickly.
    coque iphone http://xiejiadong.com/?p=1656

  41. Functions fine personally throughout VS2008. Published some sort of C# program that removes through pickup truck’s cab data along with planned to make sure the fresh record has been effectively replaced.
    coque iphone http://blog.mcerc.ge/?p=17122

  42. That surely appears like a visible scenario on the RIAA being angry which no-one is actually shopping for new music very much any more, and they’re losing money, therefore let’s take a only go after this one person and make YOUR PET pay for the belief that an incredible number of many people can also be grabbing. First of all, how can that they requirement very much funds from him intended for installing eight tracks??? The the almighty, a medication supplier wouldn’t obtain disciplined that will badly. That quantity of cash is completely silly. Secondly, shouldn’t often the RIAA be asking for other enourmous amount of people that get and also drag into court all of them intended for money too? This complete circumstance is usually absurd. Anyhow, May well… maintain battling!!
    coque iphone http://holtetpukk.no/?p=42477

  43. You happen to be wright however should you devote some more $$, then you can certainly conversion software gadgets to apply universal serial bus devices using ipad however very expensive male . -= Sunil Jain’s last site… [How to] Individualize Retweet Function with Multiauthor Wp personal blogs =-.
    coque iphone http://mikagift.com/?p=1351

  44. thanx with regard to site regarding driver lg electronics rd400 however friend Vga car owner no longer working plz work this specific new driver LG service centre consumers are purported to give you the COMPACT DISC of the necessary operators cost free. Plz strongly encourage for 1.
    coque iphone http://vmetis.org/wordpress/?p=820

  45. tou runabout set up this kind of car owner becausr this kind of to get oprating method xp not several am i able to obtain vga car owner regarding lg xnote intended for screen xp Remember to directed us vga motorist fof the lg electronics xnot rd400 succeed experience inside my mail username my very own dvd movie range of motion is displayed seeing that ejectable disk exactly what unwell complete? could you help me Hi through Carolina! Now i am weary to loss of life at the office i really thought we would have a look at your web site in the i phone throughout lunchtime break up. I enjoy the knowledge anyone provide below and cannot wait around to use a deeper look once i get home. Now i’m surprised at how fast your web blog filled on my cellular.. I am just not employing WIRELESS, just simply 3-G.. Nonetheless, exceptional blog!
    coque iphone http://tcmo.ir/?p=30649

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.


%d bloggers like this: